Guitar Bridge FMEA

From DDL Wiki

Jump to: navigation, search

Fender Failure Mode Analysis

Item & Function Failure Mode Effects of Failure S Causes of Failure P Design Controls D RPN Recommended Actions
G1 Back Panel Cover Screw
  • Attaches back panel to guitar
Screw holes may become stripped with frequent removal Back panel no longer secure, lack of panel could cause harm to bridge internals or user 4 Screw holes become stripped 4 Test number of screw/unscrew cycles before failure on test guitars 1 16 Use metal inserts, or a latch system instead of wood screws on higher end guitars
G2 Back Panel Cover
  • Protects internals of bridge from foreign objects and shocks
  • Protects user from being pinched or scratched by springs
Back panel may break when large amounts of pressure are put on it Without back panel, the bridge mechanism can become fouled on user's clothing, may pinch user 4 Plastic plate cracks 1 Test force necessary to break back pannel 2 8 Use stronger plastic back plate, or a plastic/metal plate
G4 Springs
  • Provides counter force to string tension
  • Returns bridge to tune after use of tremolo function
When springs removed for servicing, may shoot off Harm to guitar, or user 9 Springs not adequately anchored 3 Measure spring tension at factory 3 81 Design springs to be easily removable, or create anchor cable to prevent spring from flying away (like a garage door spring cable)
G5 Whammy Bar
  • Allows user to control tremolo function
Shear failure at base Broken handle, leading to an inability to use tremolo function without replacement. 7 Bar not strong enough near base 2 Test for imperfections using x-ray 7 98 Design bar to be thicker at base, where forces are greatest
Hard to tell if bar is inserted correctly 3 None (design flaw) 1 21 Design bar so it is difficult to insert incorrectly
G6 Bridge Mounting Screws
  • Pivot point for the bridge
  • Provides counter force for all forces on bridge
With excessive use, the screws may become lose Lose bridge, resulting in tuning problems 3 Bridge screws not tight 4 Measure screw tightness at factory 2 24 Use special screws designed not to work lose with operation of the bridge

Floyd Rose Failure Mode Analysis

Item & Function Failure Mode Effects of Failure S Causes of Failure P Design Controls D RPN Recommended Actions
FR1 Whammy Bar
  • Allows user to control tremolo function
Shear failure at base Broken handle, leading to an inability to use tremolo function without replacement. 7 Bar not strong enough near base 2 Test for imperfections using x-ray 7 98 Design bar to be thicker at base, where forces are greatest
Hard to tell if bar is inserted correctly 3 None (design flaw) 1 21 Design bar so it is difficult to insert incorrectly
FR2 Springs
  • Provides counter force to string tension
  • Returns bridge to tune after use of tremolo function
When springs removed for servicing, may shoot off Harm to guitar, or user 9 Springs not adequately anchored 3 Measure spring tension at factory 3 81 Design springs to be easily removable, or create anchor cable to prevent spring from flying away (like a garage door spring cable)
FR8 Clamp Screw
  • Adjusts clamp to anchor string at bridge
Screw head becomes worn Becomes impossible to unscrew screws, or change strings 3 Screw metal too soft 3 Measure screw hardness at factor 2 18 Use stronger metal for screws, or use screw head type more resistant to wear (Torx)
FR11 Tuner Spring
  • Prevents Fine Tuners from rattling
  • Keeps strings in tune
Spring bent when user services guitar Spring provides inadequate pressure on tuners 6 Spring too easy to access 3 None (design flaw) 1 18
  • Make spring harder to access
  • Include warning label
Spring too weak 3 None (design flaw) 1 18 Redesign spring to be thicker stamped piece
FR12 Baseplate
  • Base on which all components are mounted
  • Main load bearing component of bridge
  • Pivots based on user input on hardened steel "knife edges"
"Knife Edges" become dull with use Friction at pivot point increases, bridge ceases to return to pitch correctly. 5 Knife Edges not hard enough 1 Batch test knife edges for hardness 3 15 Use higher grade steel for knife edges
Too much pressure on knife edges 8 Design flaw, need pivot mechanism with larger contact area to spread pressure 1 40 Redesign pivot mechanism
Personal tools